Good stuff, and I totally agree. That's one of the things I like about the current way it is. There is no single "The Man" unit who passes his judgement on our musics.

you lost me here, though. Erroneous assumptions are not nice

I wasn't even thinking of any kind of competition. I was thinking more along the lines of "compilation" (yeah yeah I know everybody hates those), Let's make [theme themed] music events, etc where anybody can participate, but where there is incentive to try hard. It's not about being validated, it's just about having fun and doing something creative together as a group. No prizes. No money. Just time and creativity.

I just like it when things like that are sanctioned by administration, but I understand your point about "just do it yourself". Like the Stockwave thing that just happened.

What bothers me slightly is that as people transition toward Facebook pages and away from forums it makes the news thinner... It's just life and my own personal failure to embrace a different way of doing things.

I also continue to sense an invisible patricians v plebians vibe and a sense of "winners" as a matter of a person's perspective, but this happens everywhere, and isn't particular to cm.o. I am certain of it because whenever it is brought up the arguing continues until the thread is killed with no resolution.

I love that chipmusic.org doesn't get involved in these things officially because I don't want it to be defined by anything other than the tools we all use to make music. The total lack of an officially recognised competition winning track, or event featuring a few of the hundreds/thousands of artists here makes it apparent that all people and styles are welcomed here, and no-one is officially better than anyone else in the eyes of "chipmusic.org". Isn't that something you want to protect?

it's something that happens regardless~ certain users and songs on the "latest music" page get more activity than others and it's shown publicly so there is far from an equal footing in terms of musical perception here

on the compo side of things i want to stress that these things are rarely seen (or at the very least not always seen) as ways to establish  "better" or "worse" musicians than they are as a simple excuse to get people involved in writing music together and having their songs enjoyed by others as a community; perhaps monthly/seasonal chipmusic.org "write-a-longs" with synclistens and no overall vote/rank system would be more agreeable?

Sycamore Drive wrote:

Stuff

All of this is understandable and I think it's a good enough response.

seconding, has kinda convinced me to be against this, rather than for

Stuff

All of this is understandable and I think it's a good enough response.

unless you're that 8-bit girl bloke, he did not have a fun time

All you're really asking is for someone else to pony up the cash for prizes, and their time to make you feel good about yourself. "Oh look, I came 4th in the bass drum sound effect competition Summer 2013, I feel legitimised by this in the eyes of my peers".

Make your own competition, put on your own event, do your own community building exercise if you want these things to happen. It's not hard.

I don't think there is a crisis in chipmusic, because I think its next wave of sorts is eminent, what you want to do is your business.

4mat wrote:

EVERYBODY knows what this shit is now.

Let's spend 10 pages discussing that what the general public knows isn't actually chipmusic.

haha, yes.  the funny thing is I'm sure this exact arguement is on every noisecore, EDM, metal and jazz forum as well, which kind of means we "won" being a real genre.

EVERYBODY knows what this shit is now.

Let's spend 10 pages discussing that what the general public knows isn't actually chipmusic.