This is probably because of the rock/punk shows I've been going to recently, but I've been noticing that chiptune up to a certain purity forces me to write music in a way that's like stupidly specific. No matter how fancy I or anyone else gets with LSDj it's still just a sequence of loops & it'll never be as expressive or dynamic as a 4-piece rock band/orchestra/jazz trio/whatever. I can name plenty of chip songs I think are hypnotic, raw, or even beautiful, but I can't name a single chiptune song I would describe as "catchy". It's still possible to write great music but it's never going to be anything other than some fucked up techno loops trying to pass off as some other genre
Sounds like you are getting frustrated by the limitations of chip music.
Yes, you are objectively, verifiably correct. A 3-4 voice PSG will never sound as *expressive or dynamic as an Analog instrument of any sort, especially those with moving parts. it's something I struggle with as well. I have recently started using real DAWs again, and composing with samples, and midi controlled synthesizers; it's quite liberating. Don't feel as though you MUST adhere to chip purism.
If you feel you can do something with an extremely limited digital palette, do it. It's quite fun sometimes. If you feel like writing a 6 track EP in 6502 assembly code, that could be awesome.
On the other hand, If you'd like to try incorporating more instrumentation, there's nothing stopping you.
EDIT: *expressive in a sonic sense, not an emotional one.
Last edited by breakphase (Oct 27, 2016 11:28 pm)