My input from experience: ALWAYS USE A BRAND NEW RAZOR BLADE
After working on countless gameboys I have come to the conclusion that if I always use a BRAND NEW razor blade with every gameboy I NEVER have an issue.
If I ever use one that has been laying around and has been used more than once the chance that I have to spend 25 minutes with rubbing alcohol, goo gone increased dramatically.
I'd rather fork out the $2 at Wal-Mart for 5 blades than spend hours removing the leftover adhesive from the glass. (I of course use the blades for other things rather than throw them out after one use! haha)
Try it out, I bet you'd be very surprised when it works.