8-Bit-Rex wrote:The circlejerking and popularity contests have started forming here.
I don't really see any popularity contests here. It's mainly just a hard and fast focus on chiptunes and outright hate for anything else. I'm not disagreeing, it's just an observation. I wasn't active enough on 8bc's forums, but I assume they actually allowed for general discussion there instead of a stern focus on only chiptune discussion?
Was there really never any stupid shit here? I mean, I guess you could classify Swimm's and others' posts as "comedy" or "humorous," but I can't really take you guys seriously when people like Je Mapp, Swimm, Saskrotch, etc. post a bunch of ridiculous shit and it's seen as comedic gold/given a pass because they contribute to the community or have been here for a while. It's like "We can post random bullshit, but you new people?...yeah, fuck off." I mean, I like their ridiculous posts, just not the fact that everyone bitches about when other people do the same. Double standards and shit, bro.
Je Mappelle wrote:Popularity contests are awesome in my opinion, gets people really working rather than just releasing the same LSDJ album every half a year. Also when the focus is purely on music is drapes in people from all over the scene, not just people that go to chip shows.
There are pretty obvious pros and cons to this model as were discussed in that thread a couple months back. Popularity contests do seem to force people to make music and sometimes to innovate. Many times, though, they do really draw in people who will make tracks for the sole purpose of getting a lot of likes/loves/bookmarks/comments. Those songs could be innovative, they could be generic dancey shit. Regardless of their content, they were usually good on 8bc. Usually.