essentially, a real human performance is still what people identify with when it comes to music. pure chipmusic, there is arguably no human element and i think this affects the perceptions of it at a base, instinctual level. people doing fakebit concerts, mashing random buttons on their apc-40 at least appear to be interacting with the music in some way. even moreso than a kid with a gameboy.
and 'chipsounds' have been done before, look at what moog did. his synths were all about the simplest waveforms and manipulating them with envelopes and filters. the moog sound starting to become really popular once it generally moved away from arpeggiators/sequencers and more people started directly controlling it with a keyboard(real, live interaction and performance). these original 'chipsounds' touch just about every type of music now.
truchip is struggling to break out becuase the true human interaction is missing, at least fakebit can offer a little of this. i just wish people would start playing the fucking keyboard and stop having hand spasms over an apc-40.
edit:
@breakphase, "How have you objectively established the efficiency of achieving something which can only be evaluated subjectivly?"
i don't think evaluating efficiency based on average time consumption is subjective. it takes more time to go through a tracker and set volume level per note than to simply move a fader. it takes more time to make same-channel echo than it does to slap a reverb or delay vst on a track and mess with the wet/dry settings. it takes more time to figure out how to incorporate a five instrument arrangement into two pulses and a triangle, when there is no limit with DAWs and sampling. learning how to be efficient and intuitive with a tracker is, on average, a terribly time consuming chore for most people.
hey editx2:
would like to point out, if it wasn't already obvious, that this HumanElement is why bands like anamanguchi are so popular. it's why j. arthur probably had one of the best live gameboy shows. there are other instruments being played by ActualHumanHands(or use of voice!), which people can connect with.
but hey, at the same time this becomes fakebit or something