Hi Peter,
tried your YM tracker. I really like the overall concept and design of it. However I think it still needs some work to be really useful.
Here's a quick list of things that could be improved, maybe I'll add more later.
Bugs:
- Window ignores the Taskbar. Maybe add Fullscreen mode to avoid this.
- Changing the Synth Wave form seems to have no effect on the actual sound. (Maybe I'm doing it wrong though.) EDIT: yes i was doing it wrong. nevermind.
- Some typos. Arpeiggio should be Arpeggio, Node should be Note and efx are commonly abbrevated as FX.
Improvements:
- More FX should allowed in score fx column, especially arpeggio. This problem we have already with MusicMon, great instrument editor but for every little change you have to make a new instrument, which wastes a lot of space and is annoying for composers.
- The yellow bars in the vibrato/arpeggio editor should reflect the current state of the settings, rather than snap back to zero.
- Instrument editor is a bit confusing. More documentation is needed here. For example why have 2 knobs that say "Tone" resp. "Noise"? Of course the question here is where the envelope is applied. You should make that more clear somehow.
- Display total length of envelope.
- The currently edited line should be in the center of the score view, not on top.
Feature requests:
- SNDH export. Few people here will know how to convert/rip tunes from non-standard format.
- A little tab that enables you to quickly move around in the score (sequencer view). I like your concept of having a continuous score rather than single patterns. However without an overview tab it will get rather confusing.
- Freely configurable envelopes. ADSR is not enough.
- Note stop. What's "Rel" by the way?
Cheers and keep up the good work!
edit: added some stuff. also found out how to move sliders slowly and how make 100 hz instruments.