again, i just wanted to reiterate my recommendations idea in terms of how i'd like to see it implemented, just in case it got twisted through the last few pages into something that it wasn't:
1. if you're listening to a track on cm.org, there's a button you can click to recommend this track.
2. if you hover over a username anywhere on cm.org, you can see a list of 3 tracks that the user has recommended.
3. as you recommend a track, the one that was least recently recommended gets bumped off the list if the list is full.
4. maybe, if you view a track, you can see who is currently recommending it.
that's it. no charts, likes or other statistics. just wanted to see if the mods thought this is a feasible thing to implement on a technical level, and on a... moral... level? I'm legitimately curious as to how the above might be abused or twisted into something unpleasant for the community.
for the record:
- i don't really like charts either. styles and tastes are so varied that quantifying songs' worth doesn't make a lot of sense.
- i think deserving artists SHOULD be recognized. but it doesn't need to be reduced to a governing body giving you a list of what you "should" listen to you (see my point about charts).
- i think users/listeners should be proactive in finding music and sharing it with others. whether it's through making their own recommendations, or by siphoning off the recommendations of users they trust, who cares?
- i think whatever mechanism which helps people find new, good music should be self-regulating and apolitical.