egr wrote:Ok, I'll bite. Is it because of the joypad interface? Other than the fact that the "reflexes" you build using a joypad to track won't translate to really anything except LSDJ, piggy is the most clearly laid out and approachable tracker I've found.
well, how the heck is anyone going to relate to that? It's just horrible to look at, it's horrible for me and I know what I'm doing with it. Eugh. At least with pc trackers related things are either on the same screen or can be split onto the same screen. It's really difficult to associate one thing with another in this (and LSDJ's) interface, and it's the association between one part of a tracker and another that's really important for learning. I know a lot of c64 trackers have the same problem too.
It's funny, because those are the exact obstacles that I face when using PC trackers vs Piggy and LSDJ. Too much clutter on the screen. Too much scatter. Too much association. At least with LSDJ/Piggy everything is nicely organized and compartmentalized. Anti-social interface wins for me. You go to this tab to set tempo, go to that tab to make your instruments, go to the other tab to enter notes. So nice and organized, and you don't have to worry about all that other stuff when you're tryiing to focus on one thing.
And entering notes and commands with the keyboard is annoying. I'd rather just hold A and press up/down left/right. I know there are shmancy keyboard shortcuts for transposing that could achieve the same result, but it's just too much hassle.
Also, PC tracker commands are so abstract. What connection is there between the number 3xy and Legato (I actually do know why it's like this, so no need to school me, lol)
For me, having started on LSDJ, the joystick interface is the best thing ever. HivelyTracker's scroll wheel implementation is nice, too.
I figured out a nice answer to the question: The best tracker for the workshop is the one you are most comfortable with and want everybody else to use.