iLKke wrote:2. Why do you think that trackers are good for touchscreens? They are based on text input and if you try any of the existing mobile trackers you will see that they can't compare with desktop or even gamepad trackers in terms of workflow.
3. Not sure how the likes of LGPT would work on touchscreen unless some serious UI changes are made. Even games with virtual gamepads mostly play like shit. Why not use LSDJ under a GB emu on your device to see how it fits? I find it quite troublesome when I need to hold 2 virtual buttons and press the third one.
I've tried many different approaches to composing on ios. Piano rolls - way too cumbersome. You have to drag all over, pinch and zoom. I hate it. 16 step sequencers (like nanoloop) - I just find it too hard to think about the whole song in terms of little loops. That's a personal thing, as many people are good with nanoloop. So the problem with those approaches seems to be that they are not condensing enough song information on the screen.
Trackers on the other hand are super succinct. A tracker can basically be seen as a text-based musical score, scrolling vertically. The problem, as you mention, is the text part. Sunvox deals with this in a pretty intuitive way - just use a virtual piano for notes, and little keypads for the parameters.
I think something like LGPT could be made, you just have to get creative. It does require a rethink for sure.
GB emulators are no good (I've tried), for the same reason street fighter on ios/android is no good, there aren't buttons.
I actually think sunvox is great, it's mostly the navigation I don't care for.
sandneil wrote:if a tracker is "a piece of software where you press the Z key on your qwerty keyboard to enter the note C", then trackers suck on touch screen, everyone will agree. actually probably the two most popular trackers on this forum dont use a qwerty keyboard, already, tho, so its perfectly possible to tailor the tracker concept to non-qwerty input devices as was already demonstrated by lsdj/lgpt/ntrq and so on. without it losing tracker status.
Yeah that's a good point. At one time it seemed crazy to have a tracker on a 5 button device.